Making The ADA
Work for You |
Help and information are free and easy to access
by Tara Wood
Maybe you've tried to shop at a store with a building design that denied full
access to your wheelchair.
Or, you needed to take public transportation, but you were denied service
because you were accompanied by a service dog.
Or, you were fired from your job as a result of taking family leave to deal with
a medical condition.
Violations of the Americans with Disabilities Act occur in many ways and forms.
Whether small or major, intentional or inadvertent, such infringements can
happen in just about any aspect of society.
Examples like those above — patterned after actual complaints filed with the
U.S. Department of Justice — can get you fired up enough to take action.
But where do you start?
Getting information and taking the first steps to rectify an ADA violation are
easier than you might think.
In fact, teams of ADA experts are available only a phone call away. They're
ready to answer questions, sort out technical aspects of the law, and help get
you on the right path to resolving ADA-related problems — for free.
You Can Call It a ‘Dib-Tack'
As simple as its overall structure may appear, the ADA is a complex law that's
constantly being amended and interpreted. (See "ADA 101,"
for a brief outline of the law.)
That's where free services like the Disability and Business Technical Assistance
Centers (DBTACs) and the ADA Information Line can be helpful as first steps in
using the law to improve your life.
DBTACs, commonly referred to as "dib-tacks," boast a staff of ADA experts at a
network of 10 regional centers across the country. The centers are funded by a
grant from the U.S. Department of Education's National Institute on Disability
and Rehabilitation Research.
The highly trained staff members strive to provide "accurate, timely technical
assistance" on ADA-related matters, said Erica Jones, executive director of the
Pacific DBTAC, which serves California, Arizona, Hawaii, Nevada and the Pacific
Basin.
Call the DBTAC toll free number, (800) 949-4232 (see also "ADA
Resources"), during business hours, and you'll be routed automatically
to the regional center closest to your area.
Tales from the IRON BLADDER BRIGADE...

"I know it's a bit inconvenient, but file these papers and we'll correct the
access problem as soon as possible." |
According to the most recent statistics, the DBTACs nationwide fielded over
92,000 calls in 1998 and averaged 7,500 per month.
DBTAC staffers answer broad and specific questions, solve problems and consult
on an endless variety of issues, Jones said.
"We serve everybody: employers, businesses, state and local governments,
consumers with disabilities and their families, and all kinds of public
accommodations," Jones said. "We tell consumers with disabilities, ‘these are
your rights,' and other entities, such as employers, businesses, etc., ‘these
are your responsibilities.' That's how it breaks down."
ADA 101 |
Passed in 1990, the Americans with Disabilities Act prohibits
discrimination on the basis of disability in employment, state and local
government services, transportation, public accommodations and
telecommunications.
The ADA is a landmark piece of civil rights legislation, and is the result of
decades of activism to improve the lives and the role in society of people with
disabilities.
The disability rights movement was begun and led by people who were inspired by
"the struggle of African-Americans for civil rights and by the women's
movement," according to an essay on ADA history on the DBTACs' main Web site, www.adata.org/dbtac.html.
Although it's certainly the best known, the ADA wasn't the country's first step
toward legislating equality for people with disabilities. A handful of other
federal laws existed before the ADA was passed, and each was designed to
prohibit discrimination based on disability and to promote accessibility.
For example, the Architectural Barriers Act of 1968 requires that federal
buildings and facilities, and places leased by agencies receiving federal
funds, meet certain accessibility standards. Another, Section 504 of the
Rehabilitation Act of 1973, prohibits discrimination in programs or
activities that are either conducted by federal agencies or by organizations
that receive federal funds.
But while well intended, such civil rights laws were often sparsely enforced.
So, in 1986, the National Council on Disability recommended that a
comprehensive law requiring equal opportunity for people with disabilities be
enacted. The council drafted the first version of the ADA, which was introduced
in Congress in 1988, and the final version was signed into law on July 26,
1990.
The ADA was designed to fill in gaps between existing civil rights laws, and to
increase participation by people with disabilities in the mainstream of
society.
The ADA reaches farther than previous laws by applying to private entities that
aren't linked to federal funds, and to places of public accommodation (such as
restaurants, hotels, theaters and shopping centers).
It has four major titles and each is enforced by one or more federal agencies.
(The following explanations were condensed from information at www.access-board.gov and www.adata.org/dbtac.html):
Title I — Employment. Enforced by the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity
Commission.
Title II
Part A — State and local government services, programs or activities. Enforced
by the Department of Justice or its designated agencies.
Part B — Public transportation provided by public entities. Enforced by
the U.S. Department of Transportation.
Title III — Places of public accommodation and private transportation systems
that service the public. Enforced by the U.S. Department of Justice.
Title IV — Telecommunications. Enforced by the Federal Communications
Commission.
|
Getting Justice
Similarly, the U.S. Department of Justice has a toll-free ADA Information Line, (800)
514-0301, designed to help citizens and businesses understand their
rights and responsibilities under the ADA.
Information Line staff members have "significant experience in the area of
disability rights and law," Justice Department spokeswoman Casey Stavropoulos
said.
The staffers "are backed by architects and attorneys in the Disability Rights
Section that serve as sort of the second front where more nuanced technical
questions can be answered," Stavropoulos said.
The Information Line, based in Washington, operates generally during regular
business hours, Eastern Time (see "ADA Resources,").
It's also the number to call for ordering the Justice Department's technical
assistance manuals and the ADA guides published by the department.
ADA Enforcement: No Men in Black
Although the ADA specifically outlines which federal agency enforces each of its
titles, don't expect a team of government agents to swarm to the scene of a
suspected violation.
Rather, enforcement of the ADA is a complaint-driven process that depends
on citizens to call attention to problems by making formal complaints or even
filing lawsuits.
Often, the biggest challenge can be understanding whether a violation has indeed
occurred — something DBTAC and ADA Information Line staffers are trained to
determine.
However, don't count on these experts to assist you with advocacy or free legal
advice.
DBTAC staffers can guide callers to the appropriate agencies for filing
complaints, or refer them to other agencies. But Erica Jones of the Pacific
DBTAC stressed that the DBTACs aren't an ADA enforcement agency; instead, they
promote "voluntary compliance."
"We're into trying to prevent a lot of dissension between the business community
and people with disabilities," Jones said. "What we value is that our
information is not biased. It's neutral. Regardless of who calls, they should
get the same core of information."
Stavropoulos stressed that the ADA Information Line doesn't provide legal
advice, but serves mainly to clarify rights and responsibilities under the law.
The Right Way to Complain
Callers to both services can also get details about the complaint-filing
process, which differs significantly from agency to agency, depending on what
type of violation you're reporting.
For example, the process of filing a complaint for an alleged violation of ADA
Title II or Title III begins with filling out a complaint form and mailing it
to the Justice Department.
Once Justice receives the complaint, it's referred to attorneys in the
Disability Rights Section. More information may be requested, and then the case
will be reviewed to see whether mediation would be a solution, or if there's
"probable cause for litigation," Stavropoulos said.
Unfortunately, filing an ADA complaint with the Justice Department doesn't
guarantee any timeline in which the complainant will receive a response, or
ensure that any action will be taken.
"The reality is that there are lots of complaints. The Department of Justice
chooses ones that will make national significance. Any others may or may not be
heard," Jones said.
ADA Knowledge Is Power
"Put this on and get on the table. The doctor will be in
shortly." |
Although the complaint process can get bureaucratic, ADA experts hope that won't
keep people from exercising their rights guaranteed by the ADA.
Stavropoulos said it's important for citizens to know that their role is
important in the ADA process.
"There is a mechanism in place to allow citizens to inquire about their rights,
and to complain about an incident that requires attention," she said.
While the average consumer may not need to know how every aspect of the ADA
works and how its enforcement is handled, knowing generally what it affects can
be powerful, Jones said.
"The purpose of the law is to provide civil rights protection and to allow
people to fully participate in their society, and to be full members of the
community that they live in," she said. "That means everything from the right
to vote to attending a public hearing, to being able to acquire transportation,
a job, go to a movie or go to a restaurant with friends."
Jones said she wishes that people wouldn't just think of using the DBTACs after
a problem has arisen, but also for stocking up on information beforehand.
"You might just want to have information before there is a problem so that you
can resolve something with knowledge. Like going to the museum — do they have
to let a service animal in? Or do they have to let a wheelchair in if it says
no mobility aids allowed?" Jones said.
"Ah! THERE'S the other curbcut!" |
And although there are still a lot of problematic issues to be resolved with the
ADA, it's remarkable to look at the impact the 12-year-old law has already
made, she said.
Prior to the ADA, many people with disabilities were constantly left out because
the entrance to a building was impossible to use, or bathrooms weren't
accessible.
"All those things are now different. There are still problems and there's still
a long way to go. But if you look out in your community, there are curb cuts
where they've never been before," Jones said.
"Mothers with baby strollers think they're for them. Workmen with dollies think
they're for them. People who use skateboards think they're there for them.
That's called universal design and I think it's a wonderful outcome." 
For many people with neuromuscular diseases, there usually isn't any question
about whether they have a physical disability that greatly affects their
lifestyle.
But for people with a variety of other physical or mental conditions, there's
often plenty of discussion and sometimes legal wrangling on whether they are,
by definition, disabled. The answer to that question determines whether they're
"covered" by provisions of the Americans with Disabilities Act.
Under the ADA, an individual with a disability is: "a person who has a physical
or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more major life
activities, has a record of such an impairment, or is regarded as having such
an impairment."
The scope of that definition has been in the news in recent months, and promises
to continue to be newsworthy as the U.S. Supreme Court hears several cases
having to do with ADA violations.
Employment Cases
Disability rights activists have protested court decisions they fear are
dangerously narrowing the interpretation of what constitutes a disability, and
creating a "catch-22" for many people. Many of the cases that have reached the
nation's top court concern the rights of employees with disabilities.
One case, Toyota Motor Mfg. v. Williams, has galvanized disability rights
activists. Ella Williams was an automobile assembly line employee who developed
carpal tunnel syndrome as a result of repetitive motions in her work.
The Supreme Court unanimously agreed that, since Williams' continuing ability to
perform "major life activities" — such as brushing her teeth, bathing and doing
some household chores — disqualified her from fitting within the ADA's
definition of disability, it excluded her from claiming a right to reasonable
accommodations from her employer.
Such interpretation means "you are either not disabled enough to be covered by
the ADA or you are too disabled to do the job," wrote attorney Arlene Mayerson,
in a Friend of the Court brief for the National Council on Disability.
"At the same time [injured workers] are trying to show how much the impairment
affects their daily life, they are also trying to prove they are qualified for
the job. By proving you're disabled, you can prove yourself right out of a
job," wrote Mayerson, directing attorney for the Disability Rights Education
and Defense Fund.
In another case that has garnered national attention, the Supreme Court ruled
that the ADA doesn't normally require companies to bend their seniority rules
so disabled employees can have particular jobs.
In U.S. Airways v. Barnett, the airline had invoked its seniority system
to deny an injured baggage handler the right to stay in a less physically
taxing job in the mailroom where he had been temporarily assigned but in which
he didn't have sufficient seniority to remain.
Disability rights activists saw the late April ruling as another setback for
workers with disabilities and part of a disturbing trend that narrows the reach
of the ADA.
Justin Dart, chairman of the ADA Watch National Advisory Committee, who is
widely considered to be the "father of the ADA," said in a statement on www.ican.com that the ruling signals a need for action by people with
disabilities.
"Little known effect of the Americans with Disabilities Act" |
"There isn't any doubt in the world that there is a bias against us on the
Supreme Court," Dart said. "We need to create a public and political
consciousness that makes it unacceptable to take away our rights and
unacceptable to appoint judges who threaten the ADA."
At least one more pivotal ADA decision is expected from the court before it
adjourns this summer. In fact, Justice Sandra Day O'Connor was quoted earlier
this year as calling this term the "disabilities act term" for the number of
cases dealing with the ADA. She also criticized the legislation for being
passed too hastily.
"It's an example of what happens when ... the sponsors are so eager to get
something passed that what passes hasn't been as carefully written as a group
of law professors might put together," she said at a lawyers conference in
March.
Keeping an Eye Out
The ADA will continue to change the way our society is designed and functions,
and so, too, will the way courts, businesses and individuals interpret the law
and its provisions.
Several Internet sites track court news and current events having to do with the
ADA and disability.
- www.adawatch.com
An online network designed to "activate grassroots responses to threats to the
ADA."
- www.dredf.org
Home page for the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund.
- www.jfanow.org
The Justice for All E-mail Network was formed to "defend and advance disability
rights and programs in the 104th Congress" and to get information from
Washington out to grassroots organizations.
- www.ican.com
A disability community on the Internet that includes news coverage of issues of
interest.
ADA Resources |
|
General ADA Information
Disability and Business Technical Assistance Centers
(800) 949-4232
Call for information, materials, technical assistance or training on the ADA.
This number will automatically route your call to the DBTAC in your region.
www.adata.org/dbtac.html
ADA Information Line, operated by the U.S. Department of Justice
(800) 514-0301
Call to obtain answers to general and technical questions about the ADA and to
order technical assistance materials.
Hours are Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday and Friday from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. and
Thursday from 1 to 6 p.m. Eastern Time. Spanish language service is available.
The Department's ADA home page at www.usdoj.gov/crt/ada/adahom1.htm includes information about
employment, public accommodations and other ADA topics.
www.access-board.gov
This is the Web site for the U.S. Architectural and Transportation Barriers
Compliance Board, also known as the Access Board, an independent federal agency
that enforces the Architectural Barriers Act. The site explains accessibility
standards and the laws that govern them, including a comprehensive list of
where many public and private entities fall under the ADA.
www.eeoc.gov
The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission's Web site features frequently
asked questions about job discrimination, and explains how to file a
discrimination charge. |
Job Accommodation Network
(800) 526-7234
This free consulting service provides information about job accommodations, the
ADA and the employability of people with disabilities.
janweb.icdi.wvu.edu
For ADA Violations
- Title I — Employment
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
Call to be automatically connected with the nearest EEOC field office.
(800) 669-4000
www.eeoc.gov
- Title II — State and local government services, programs or activities
Part A: U.S. Department of Justice
(800) 514-0301
www.usdoj.gov/crt/ada/adahom1.htm
Part B: U.S. Department of Transportation, Federal Transit Administration's ADA
Assistance Line for regulations and complaints
(888) 446-4511
www.fta.dot.gov/office/civ.htm
e-mail: ada.assistance@fta.dot.gov
- Title III — Public accommodation and private transportation
U.S. Department of Justice (see Title II).
- Title IV — Telecommunications
Federal Communications Commission
(888) 225-5322
www.fcc.gov/cgb/dro
|
|